Why Does George Kill Lennie Essay

Of Mice and Men: George Killed Lennie for Merciful Reasons

Get Your
Essay Written

Starting at Just $13.90 a page

Of Mice and Men: George Killed Lennie for Merciful Reasons A true friendship is one in which friends care deeply enough to anticipate one another’s needs and are willing to put their friend’s needs before their own. Their mutual love enables them to make sacrifices only to protect each other. In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, George killing Lennie is a merciful kill to save others from Lennie’s unintentional acts of aggression, to spare Lennie from suffering a cruel death, and instead ensuring a peaceful and quick departure one that will cause George the least regrets.

George begins to see a pattern of aggression coming from Lennie and wants to put it to an end because Lennie is hurting too many others unintentionally and he sees Lennie is quick to frustrate and panic and is lacking in the ability to control his violent reactions. Lennie has killed many mice, a pup, and finally a woman. Although Lennie may not want to kill any other living beings, it is in his nature to become aggressive and angry when frustrated. He typically believes he “‘wasn’t doin’ nothing bad’ ” (Steinbeck 9) with the mice and he was “‘Jus’ strokin’ it’ ” (Steinbeck 9).

He cannot contain his anger and that often leads to an unrestrained use of his strength. Because Lennie never has the intention to kill anything, he can feel an immense amount of guilt and remorse as seen when he runs out of the barn crying, “‘I done a real bad thing… I shouldn’t of did that’” (Steinbeck 92), after killing Curley’s wife. Despite Lennie’s remorse, he does not grasp the severity and the consequences of his actions. This is not so much due to Lennie’s slowness but more because of George’s protective nature, preventing Lennie from ever having to face any consequences.

Nonetheless, George sees that Lennie is unable to learn from his mistakes and fears the pattern is going to continue and that he is unable to change Lennie. George feels justified in killing Lennie because he knows that in the long run he would be able to spare many other lives and prevent Lennie from all the pain and anguish from the remorse Lennie feels after his aggressions. George’s decision to kill his best friend is to prevent a horrific and undeserved fate that awaits Lennie unless there is some intervention. He does not want Lennie to be killed by Curley or sent to jail.

George clearly can sense Curley’s anger and vindictive nature about Lennie killing his wife. It is quite apparent that Curley wants justice and revenge and is determined to make Lennie suffer: “Curley’s face reddened. ‘I’m goin’… I’m gonna shoot the guts outta that big bastard myself” (Steinbeck 98). Shooting Lennie in the gut would cause he him to slowly bleed to death, ensuring a long, painful death. Even if Curley is not to succeed in killing Lennie in this gruesome manner, the other likely outcome is that Lennie is sentenced and put in jail for potentially a lifetime.

Initially, in light of the possibility of Curley’s revenge, George considers jail to be a safe haven: “Guess… We gotta tell the… guys. I guess we gotta get ‘im an’ lock ‘im up. We can’t let ‘im get away… ’ And he tries to reassure himself, ‘Maybe they’ll lock ‘im up and be nice to ‘im” (Steinbeck 94). However, upon further consideration, George realizes that Lennie is incapable of living on his own and fending for himself in jail and will not last. Either outcome would result in a miserable and slow death for Lennie, and George could not allow this to happen to his best friend.

This is how he reaches the conclusion that it is necessary for George, himself, to kill Lennie in a humane fashion in order to give him a quick and peaceful death. By shooting Lennie himself, George minimizes his own pain for not letting Lennie die at the hands of a stranger and can also control Lennie’s last thoughts and feelings. Earlier on in the novella, Candy feels deep regret for not being the one to end his dog’s life and he tells George, “’I oughtta shot that dog myself… I shouldn’t oughtta let no stranger shoot my dog’” (Steinbeck 61).

Candy and his dog were lifelong friends and companions, as were Lennie and George. Candy’s regret makes a lasting impression and Georges recognizes that he too cannot live letting anyone else take Lennie’s life. Moreover, he ensures that Lennie last moments are filled with joyous thoughts as he strikes up a conversation about Lennie’s favorite topic: “’And I get to tend the rabbits. ’” (Steinbeck 105) said Lennie, “‘An’ you get to tend the rabbits. ’”(Steinbeck 105) responded George, then “Lennie giggled with happiness. ” (Steinbeck 105).

Do you like
this material?Get help to write a similar one

And lastly, as George’s last act of friendship, he reassures Lennie with his final words that is he is not mad at Lennie nor that he’s ever been. This is to award Lennie with as much peace as a friend could. Overall, Lennie is in a much better place once he dies. He does not to suffer a long and painful death; he would not hurt any other humans or animals and is spared the resulting remorse. George feels great loss and is shaken afterward despite knowing he is justified in actions. This is a compassionate homicide and George is a true friend. He looks out for Lennie’s needs and makes sacrifices to the end.

Author: Josh Garten

in Of Mice and Men

Of Mice and Men: George Killed Lennie for Merciful Reasons

We have so large base of authors that we can prepare a unique summary of any book. Don't believe? Check it!

How fast would you like to get it?


Of Mice and Men was an awe inspiring book about a couple of men just trying to get by in the Great Depression. George and Lennie had known each other for a very long time and had grown to depend on each other. Throughout the book Lennie asked George to tell him about them, about how they were going to get a place and live together, they never got to do that, as life would have it, reality got in the way. The most controversial topic from this book was why George killed Lennie. It was the right thing to do for multiple reasons, the first being that Lennie was a danger to those around him as well as himself, the second is that Lennie could not survive without George and the last being that if George didn’t, Curly would have.

It’s clear from the beginning that Lennie has caused trouble for George. In the very first chapter George and Lennie had run away from Weed because Lennie had caused trouble for them. He had reached out and grabbed a woman’s dress and she started screaming, as we later found out, and all he had done was hold onto her dress tighter, scaring her so badly that they’d been run out of town by the police. George told Slim later on that he had once told Lennie to jump into a river and he’d nearly drowned. That, and when Curly attacked Lennie and Lennie failed to protect himself proves that he was indeed a danger to himself. He is also proven to be a danger to others when he kills his puppy and snaps Curly’s wife’s neck because he had no understanding of his own strength.

Lennie was also incapable of caring for himself. He counted on George for everything, including when to protect himself. Lennie shows that he is practically incapable of thinking for himself. George has to find them work, food, housing and has to bail Lennie out of trouble. I believe by the end of this book George realized that he just couldn’t take care of Lennie forever but he was going to do his best while he could, which includes choosing to execute him himself.

George knew he had to kill Lennie himself because if he didn’t Lennie would either be locked up, or more likely, Curly would have killed him. Curly clearly states that he was going to shoot Lennie in the gut so that he died slowly and painfully and George knew that Lennie didn’t deserve that. He knew that the best thing he could do for Lennie at that point was to find him first and spare him that miserable fate. By doing that George proved he loved Lennie and that he knew what was right for him. He spared Lennie from dying scared and tortured.

George loved Lennie and killing him was one of the most selfless things he would ever do. In the end George comforted Lennie, told him their story again so the last thoughts Lennie had were happy ones. If George hadn’t killed Lennie he would’ve regretted it the rest of his life and betrayed not only himself but Lennie as well. Georges promise was to protect and care for Lennie, and he did that better than anyone else could have. Killing Lennie was the right thing to do.

© Copyright 2018 ShelBell. All rights reserved.

0 Replies to “Why Does George Kill Lennie Essay”

Lascia un Commento

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *